Yes, sorry if I made that more complex than it should have.
All that time I think Spuz and I were discussing the same thing in different ways, haha.
But I blame Sega! Dastardly fellows. Don't trust 'em.
That guide is fine, but it doesn't mention having the present given to the females from the same account in which the chocolate was made. It has to be the same account otherwise it won't work.